Why Your SAD Lamp Isn't Working (What to Do Instead)

Winter depression is real, and it's brutal! You bought the lamp. You read the reviews. You set it up on your desk thinking "this is it, this will fix my winter blues."

You've been using it for three weeks—maybe six—and you're still dragging yourself out of bed at 8 AM feeling like you've been hit by a truck. The afternoon fog still rolls in around 2 PM. The motivation to do anything after work? Still missing. Sound familiar?

"Maybe I'm just depressed," you think. "Maybe SAD lamps don't work for me." I thought the same thing my first winter here.

Here's the thing: SAD lamps work. But most people are using them completely wrong. And worse, most SAD lamps on the market aren't actually delivering what you need. I've tested enough of them to know—and I've made most of these mistakes myself.

The Problem: Most SAD Lamp Advice is Oversimplified

Go to any Norwegian health website, and here's what you'll read:

"Get a 10,000 lux SAD lamp. Use it for 30 minutes in the morning. Problem solved!"

Sounds simple, right? Except it misses about five critical factors that determine whether light therapy actually works. I learned this the hard way after my first winter using one incorrectly when I didn't have other things in place.

The factors:

1. When you use it (timing is everything)
2. How far you sit from it (most people get this wrong)
3. What spectrum it's emitting (not all "white light" is equal)
4. What you're doing while using it (scrolling Instagram defeats the purpose)
5. What your light environment looks like the rest of the day (this is the big one)

Get any of these wrong, and your expensive SAD lamp becomes an overpriced desk ornament. I know because I've been there. I still have a SAD lamp but I use it rarely because I have fixed other issues. Some people haven't the time to do all those things so let us continue and help you so that your SAD lamp can have a positive effect on you this winter. REMEMBER I DON'T SELL SAD LAMPS - THIS IS JUST A BLOG TO HELP THOSE OF YOU THAT HAVE ONE.

Why Most SAD Lamps Fail (The Real Reasons)

1. You're Using It at the Wrong Time

This is the biggest mistake I see—and the one I made myself. People use their SAD lamp "whenever they remember" or "while working at their desk" or "in the evening to feel better." I used to turn mine on at 3 PM during the afternoon slump. Completely wrong.

Here's what actually matters: Your brain has a circadian clock, and that clock is ONLY adjustable during specific time windows. Miss those windows and you're basically wasting your time.

Research on circadian biology makes this clear: Light is a zeitgeber—a "time giver." It doesn't just make you "feel good" temporarily. It tells your brain's master clock what time it is, which then cascades into hormone production, body temperature, metabolism... everything.

Your circadian system has two key windows:

Phase Advance Window: First 2-3 hours after your natural wake time

• Light exposure here shifts your rhythm earlier (helps with winter oversleeping)
• This is when morning light therapy actually works
• This is your golden window—don't miss it

Phase Delay Window: Evening (roughly 6-10 PM)

• Light exposure here shifts your rhythm later (makes it harder to wake up)
• This is when evening light therapy backfires spectacularly
• You're essentially telling your brain "it's still daytime, don't make melatonin yet"

If you're using your SAD lamp at 2 PM "because that's when I feel tired," you're outside both windows. You might get a temporary mood boost (from blue light suppressing melatonin—which you actually need during the day for its antioxidant properties), but you're not fixing the underlying circadian problem. You're just masking it.

Worse: If you're using it in the evening to "boost your mood" or "get more done," you're actively making your winter sleep problem worse. I did this for weeks before I figured out why I couldn't fall asleep until midnight. Don't be like me.

2. You're Sitting Too Far Away

Here's the dirty secret about lux ratings that the manufacturers don't emphasize: They're meaningless without distance.

That "10,000 lux" lamp? That's measured at a specific distance—usually 30-50cm from the panel. If you're sitting 1 meter away (which most people do because who wants a bright light in their face while trying to work?), you're getting maybe 2,000-3,000 lux. Maybe less if it's angled.

The inverse square law is brutal: Double the distance, you get 1/4 of the light intensity. Physics doesn't care about your comfort.

Reality check: Most people set up their SAD lamp on their desk, about 60-100cm away, angled to the side so it doesn't glare into their screens. They think they're getting 10,000 lux. They're getting 1,500-3,000 lux if they're lucky.

That's not enough to reliably phase-shift your circadian rhythm. The research showing SAD lamps work used 10,000 lux actually reaching your eyes, not "10,000 lux somewhere in the general vicinity." Again, this isn't an attack, this is something I have learned and I want to share this with you so that you can fair better than I did. I wish someone had told me!

I measured mine with a proper lux meter (they're cheap, about 300kr on Amazon). Sitting where I thought I was getting 10,000 lux? I was getting 2,100 lux. No wonder it wasn't working as it could do. You can even download some free apps and have a rough guide on how strong yours is.

3. Your Lamp Has the Wrong Spectrum

Not all "white light" is the same, and this is where it gets technical. Your SAD lamp is probably one of three types:

Type 1: Cool white LED (5000-6500K) - Lots of blue light (460-480nm), minimal red and infrared, harsh and unnatural. This is what most cheap SAD lamps use.

Type 2: Full-spectrum fluorescent - Better spectrum but still missing red/NIR, contains UV (minimal), potential flicker issues if it's an older model with magnetic ballast.

Type 3: "Natural" white LED (4000-5000K) - Less blue than Type 1, still missing red and infrared, often flickers with PWM dimming (more on this later).

Here's what matters for circadian signaling: Your circadian system responds primarily to blue light (460-480nm) hitting specific photoreceptors called melanopsin cells in your retina. These are separate from your regular vision cells. That part, most SAD lamps get right because blue light is cheap to produce.

But there's a problem: Blue light alone is not what your biology expects in the morning. Natural sunlight—even in winter, even in cloudy Norway—contains blue (circadian signaling), green (contrast and depth perception), and red and near-infrared (mitochondrial support, retinal health).

When you blast your eyes with pure blue-enriched light from a SAD lamp for 30 minutes every morning, you're:

• ✓ Signaling your circadian clock (good—this is the main goal)
• ✗ Providing zero mitochondrial support to your retina (not ideal)
• ✗ Creating an unnatural, stressful light environment (can cause issues)

This is why some people get headaches, eye strain, or feel "wired but tired" from SAD lamps. I got terrible headaches my first week until I figured out I needed to add red light therapy separately. More on that later.

4. Your Melanopsin Cells are Saturated

Here's something most people don't know, and honestly I didn't know this until I went down the rabbit hole of circadian biology: melanopsin photoreceptors saturate quickly.

Once they're activated, more light doesn't do proportionally more. You hit diminishing returns fast. It's not like charging a battery where more time = more charge.

The research shows 10,000 lux for 30 minutes works. But 20,000 lux for 60 minutes doesn't work twice as well. You've already saturated the receptors. They're firing maximally after about 20-30 minutes at proper intensity.

The problem: People think "more light = better results" and sit in front of their SAD lamp for 2 hours while working. This doesn't give you 4x the benefit. It gives you eye strain, headaches, and possibly some retinal stress. Diminishing returns doesn't even cover it—you might actually be doing slight harm.

5. You're Undermining It the Rest of the Day

This is the one that nobody talks about, and it's probably the most important. Light therapy isn't just about what you do for 30 minutes in the morning. It's about your entire 24-hour light environment. I cannot stress this enough—I've harped on about this before and I'll keep doing it.

If you're doing this:

• ✓ 10,000 lux SAD lamp at 7 AM for 30 minutes (good start)
• ✗ Sitting in a dark office all day with just a computer screen (terrible)
• ✗ Bright overhead LEDs at 9 PM while scrolling your phone (very bad)
• ✗ Instagram in bed at 11 PM with full screen brightness (catastrophic)

...then your SAD lamp is trying to fix a problem you're recreating every single evening. You're swimming against the current. It might sound like a lot of effort and lots to think about, but it really isn't when you get into the swing of things.

Your circadian system needs contrast and consistency. It needs bright, blue-enriched light in the morning (photon density + spectrum), moderate natural light during the day (not sitting in a cave), dim, red-shifted light in the evening (no blue after sunset), and actual darkness at night (not "mostly dark with a phone screen").

If you nail the morning light perfectly and then destroy it every evening with bright lights and screens, you're basically wasting your time. The evening light exposure is more powerful than most people realize.

What Actually Works: The Complete Light Protocol

Here's what I figured out after two winters of experimenting (and making mistakes):

Morning Protocol (The Critical Window)

Timing: Within 30 minutes of waking, earlier is better. I aim for within 10 minutes. Summer time - go outside. Mid-winter then grab some light panel if you need it.

Duration: 10-30 minutes, not more. Diminishing returns kick in hard after 30 minutes.

Distance: 30-40cm from your face. Yes, it's close. Yes, it feels weird at first. Do it anyway.

Angle: 30-45° above your eye line, like where the sun would be mid-morning. Not straight ahead like a computer screen. If it is very early and you have incandescent bulbs or other near infrared emitting bulbs you can use a lower angle below your eye line to mimic sunrise.

Activity: Something calm—breakfast, journaling, coffee, reading. Not intense work that requires screen focus. I usually have mine on while I'm making and eating breakfast. Simple.

Why this works: You're hitting your melanopsin cells during the phase-advance window, at an intensity that actually matters (because you're close enough), with light coming from the direction your brain expects (sun comes from above, not straight ahead from a desk lamp).

Daytime Light Exposure (The Missing Piece Nobody Talks About)

This is what most SAD lamp users completely ignore, and it's honestly more important than the SAD lamp itself: you need daytime light, not just morning light. The morning light sets your clock, but daytime light maintains the signal.

Even on a cloudy Norwegian winter day, outdoor light is 5,000-10,000 lux. Indoor office lighting? 300-500 lux. That's a 10-20x difference. Your brain can absolutely tell the difference.

Your circadian system needs contrast: bright morning, moderate day, dim evening. If you go from bright morning (SAD lamp) to dark day (office cave) to bright evening (overhead LEDs + screens), your brain gets confused signals.

Practical solution:

• Get outside for 10-15 minutes midday, ideally around lunch. Even if it's cloudy. Even if it's cold. Just do it.
• Sit near windows during the day if you work indoors
• Use a bright daylight (5000K) desk lamp at your workspace—not for circadian signaling, just to avoid living in a cave

This changed everything for me. The SAD lamp alone did maybe 30% of what I needed. Adding midday outdoor time got me to 70%. It's not optional if you want this to actually work.

Evening Protocol (Stop Sabotaging Yourself)

Most people are doing more damage in the evening than their SAD lamp can fix in the morning. I see this constantly. Bright overhead LEDs until 11 PM, scrolling phones in bed—and then wondering why they can't sleep.

The hard rules (yes, they're hard, but they work):

• Dim all lights after sunset. Yes, really. I know it feels weird at first.
• No overhead LEDs after 8 PM. Use lamps instead—low, warm (2700K), and preferably with salt lamps or incandescent if you can find them.
• Blue light blocking glasses after 9 PM, or dim your screens way down (like 20% brightness or lower).
• No phone in bed. Buy an actual alarm clock. They still make those.

I know, this sounds extreme. I resisted it for months. "Surely it can't matter that much," I thought. Wrong.

Here's the thing: a single bout of bright light at 10 PM can shift your circadian phase by 1-2 hours. That's as powerful as your morning light therapy—but in the wrong direction. One evening of bright light exposure can undo days of proper morning protocol.

The Red Light Addition (What I Wish I'd Known from the Start)

After learning about mitochondrial health and retinal photoreceptors, I added red light therapy to my morning protocol. This wasn't in any SAD lamp instruction manual, but it makes a massive difference.

Protocol: 5-10 minutes of red (600+nm) + near-infrared (800+nm) light to my closed eyelids, AFTER the blue-rich SAD lamp session.

Why: Red and NIR light support mitochondrial function in your retina and skin. Your eyes need energy to maintain themselves—they're metabolically expensive organs. During Norwegian winter when they're getting zero red/NIR from the environment (because you're never outside and indoor lighting has none), they're essentially running on fumes.

Practical stack:

• 7:00 AM: SAD lamp (20 min, eating breakfast) - circadian signaling
• 7:25 AM: Red light panel (5-10 min, eyes closed) - mitochondrial support for retina and brain

This combination hits both angles: circadian reset + cellular energy support. The SAD lamp tells your brain what time it is. The red light gives your cells the energy to function properly. Together, they're much more effective than either alone.

You can also use a red light mask for this—I sometimes use my PulseWave Pro mask if I'm short on time. It sits right on your face so you don't have to worry about distance or positioning.

The Device Question (What Actually Matters)

After testing multiple SAD lamps over two winters, here's what actually makes a difference:

1. Actual Lux Output at Working Distance

Don't trust the marketing numbers. Seriously. They're always measured at optimal distance. Either measure it yourself with a lux meter (cheap investment, around 300-500kr), or sit close enough that you're confident you're getting actual therapeutic levels.

If you can't measure, use the "too bright to be comfortable" rule. If it's not slightly uncomfortable to look near (not at—near), you're probably too far away.

2. Spectrum

Cool white (5000-6500K) works for circadian signaling—that's the primary goal. But if you're getting eye strain or headaches (like I did), look for full-spectrum options, or add red light separately (which I recommend anyway), or make sure you're spending time outdoors (best option, but not always practical in Norwegian winter).

3. Flicker

If your SAD lamp is flickering (usually from PWM dimming), you'll get headaches. I suffered through this for two weeks before I figured out the flicker was the problem. Look for flicker-free models with proper constant current drivers.

Test: Point your phone camera at the lamp. If you see bands rolling or flickering on your screen, the lamp is flickering. Return it. Don't compromise on this—flicker-induced headaches are miserable.

4. Size

Bigger is better, period. You want a large, diffuse light source that mimics the sky, not a small, intense point source like a spotlight. Minimum 30x30cm surface area. Bigger if you can afford it and have the space.

Small "portable" SAD lamps are usually too weak and too small to be effective. They're convenient, but convenience doesn't fix seasonal depression.

The Honest Truth About SAD Lamps

SAD lamps can work (they are not ideal and outside would be best, but in Norway, best isn't always an option)—but only if you use them correctly. And "correctly" means a lot more than the instruction manual tells you:

1. Use them at the right time (first thing in morning, within 30 minutes of waking)
2. Sit close enough (30-40cm, measured with a lux meter if possible)
3. Use them consistently (every single day, no exceptions during winter months)
4. Fix your daytime light environment (get outside for 10-15 minutes midday)
5. Stop sabotaging yourself at night (dim lights after sunset, blue light blockers after 9 PM, no screens in bed)

If you're doing #1-5, a SAD lamp will help. If you're missing any of these—especially #4 and #5—you're probably wasting your time and money.

My honest experience over two winters: The SAD lamp alone did maybe 30% of what I needed. Adding multiple outdoor time sessions (think smoking breaks without the smoking) got me to 70%. Fixing my evening light environment (dimming lights, blue blockers, no screens) got me to 90%. Adding red light therapy in the morning got me to 95%.

The last 5%? That's diet, sleep quality, exercise, stress management—the things that always matter regardless of season.

What I Do Now (The Full Protocol That Actually Works)

6:30 AM (Winter - summer I am outside)

• Red Light Therapy 5 minutes - face
  
• Mitochondrial support for eyes and brain tissue
• SAD lamp (10,000 lux at 30cm, 10 minutes)
  
• Red Light therapy - whole body including face 8-10 minutes
• Making and eating breakfast, not trying to work
• Light positioned 45° above eye line, like morning sun
• Sometimes, if rushed, I will combine the two and put the SAD lamp on top the red light panel.

Morning - Lunch - afternoon 

• 10-30 minute walk outside, even if it's cloudy and cold
• This is non-negotiable, it's more important than the SAD lamp for me personally.
• Critical for maintaining daytime signal and getting actual daylight
• Whether you notice it or not, the ratios and strengths of the light are different each time you go out so you are anchoring your body clock to the real clock in the sky.

6:00 PM onwards

• Dim all overhead lights, switch to low lamps only
• Warm (2700K) bulbs only in the evening
• Blue light blocking glasses go on around 8-9 PM
• Screen brightness down to minimum if I have to use devices

10:00 PM

• Pitch black bedroom—blackout curtains, tape over any LED lights (not completely necessary but you would be amazed at how much light can be produced by small LED lights in your room). Other wise, take anything with an LED out of your room
• No screens, no phone (charging in another room)
• Eye mask if needed for complete darkness -think summer time when it is light until late and bright very early in the morning!

Result after sticking to this for 6 weeks: You should wake up naturally at 6:30-7:00 AM, even in January when it's pitch black outside. Energy throughout the day. Actual motivation to do things after work instead of just collapsing on the sofa. No more 2 PM energy crash. Sleep quality dramatically improved.

The SAD lamp is part of the solution, an important part, but it's not the whole solution. Anyone telling you otherwise is either selling something or hasn't actually dealt with Norwegian winter depression.

The Bottom Line

Your SAD lamp isn't working because you're using it at the wrong time (or wrong time of day relative to your circadian phase), you're sitting too far away (probably getting 2,000-3,000 lux instead of 10,000), you're undermining it with evening light exposure (the biggest mistake), you're missing critical daytime outdoor light (the second biggest mistake), and you're expecting it to do all the work (it won't).

What to do instead:

• Use it within 30 minutes of waking, every single day
• Sit 30-40cm away for 10-30 minutes, verify with a lux meter if possible
• Get outside for 10-15 minutes around multiple times per day, non-negotiable. How many times you get out is up to you.
• Dim all lights after sunset, use blue light blockers after 9 PM
• Consider adding red light therapy for mitochondrial support (game-changer for me)

This isn't what the SAD lamp box says. It's not what your doctor probably told you. But it's what actually works.

If you've been frustrated with SAD lamps and winter depression, try this complete protocol for 2-3 weeks. Not just the lamp - the whole thing. The difference is measurable. I track my sleep, mood, and energy levels, and the data is clear and has been clear for years.

Norwegian winters are brutal on our biology. But we can work with our biology instead of against it.

---

Want to learn more?

Check out our guide on building a complete home light therapy protocol or browse our light therapy collection and blue light blocking glasses.

Questions? Drop them in the comments below. I read and respond to all of them.